Common Baking Mistakes You’re Probably Making (And How To Avoid Them)

Baking requires careful thought, patience, and determination. If your recipes aren't turning out quite right, it's possible that you're making one of these all-too-common baking mistakes.

Here are eight mistakes that could be impacting your cookies, cakes, and other baked goods.

Not measuring ingredients

samee-anderson-qa6dwVxR2h0-unsplash
Samee Anderson/Unsplash
Samee Anderson/Unsplash

Baking is a science, which is why it's important to follow the recipe as best you can. When measuring ingredients, accuracy is everything.

Too much or too little of certain ingredients can completely change the texture and flavor of a baked good. Be sure to use a measuring cup or scale whenever possible.

ADVERTISEMENT

Over-mixing the batter

ADVERTISEMENT
callum-hill-LdK3Q7AAGPc-unsplash
Callum Hill/Unsplash
Callum Hill/Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Mixing flour with liquids is the key to maintaining the structure of baked goods. However, there is such a thing as too much mixing.

ADVERTISEMENT

Over-mixing batter can cause dough to become tough and chewy due to an overdevelopment of gluten. For the best results, mix your batter only until there are no more visible streaks of flour.

ADVERTISEMENT

Using substitutions that don't make sense

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
olimpia-davies-0Kcxl_KEPhM-unsplash
Olimpia Davies/Unsplash
Olimpia Davies/Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

We've all experienced the panic of realizing we're out of a key ingredient while baking. It may seem reasonable to find add more of a different ingredient to make up for it, but this can quickly lead to a baking disaster.

ADVERTISEMENT

Recipes are tested and written with intention, so substitutions can be risky. It's best to choose a recipe that includes ingredients you actually have on hand.

ADVERTISEMENT

Not scraping the bowl

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ahmet-koc-FPfkNagXawM-unsplash
Ahmet Koç/Unsplash
Ahmet Koç/Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Scraping the bowl after adding new ingredients helps prevent large clumps in your batter. Silicone spatulas are the best option for scraping because they are smooth and pliable.

ADVERTISEMENT

Be sure to scrape excess ingredients from all areas of your mixing bowl for a clump-free batter.

ADVERTISEMENT

Not chilling the dough

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
pam-mene-mo7y6AO_r5I-unsplash
Pam Mene/Unsplash
Pam Mene/Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

If a recipe asks you to chill the dough for a certain amount of time, it's important to not to skip this step.

ADVERTISEMENT

Chilling the dough prevents cookies from spreading too much in the oven. It also helps concentrate the flower and let gluten relax, leading to softer and more tender baked goods.

ADVERTISEMENT

Not greasing your pans correctly

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
yunus-tug-eJ2_eXhrU2Y-unsplash (1)
Yunus Tuğ/Unsplash
Yunus Tuğ/Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Greasing your pans properly is an essential step in the baking process. A well-greased pan prevents baked goods from sticking to the pan and causing a big mess.

ADVERTISEMENT

Baking sheets can be greased using butter, nonstick cooking spray, or parchment paper. If you're not sure which method is best, check the recipe for specification.

ADVERTISEMENT

Baking at the wrong temperature

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
getty-images-fpF7K4tRob0-unsplash
Getty Images/Unsplash
Getty Images/Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Your oven should always be fully pre-heated before use. If the oven is not at the right temperature when you put in your batter or dough, it can alter the baking time and consistency of the baked good.

ADVERTISEMENT

For extra precision, consider using an oven thermometer to double check the oven's temperature before baking.

ADVERTISEMENT

Not letting cakes cool before frosting

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
aneta-voborilova-PmZXlUasoxg-unsplash (1)
Aneta Voborilova/Unsplash
Aneta Voborilova/Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

If your cake or cupcakes are too warm, the frosting may melt or cause the cakes to become a crumbly mess. This is why it's best to let cakes cool completely before decorating.

ADVERTISEMENT

If you want to speed up the process, let the cakes cool on wire racks for half and hour and then transport them to the fridge to finish cooling.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
getty-images-QBwntmUP7gk-unsplash
Getty Images/Unsplash
Getty Images/Unsplash
ADVERTISEMENT

Baking doesn't need to be overly complicated. With a few small adjustments, you'll be whipping up cookies and cakes in no time.

ADVERTISEMENT

Avoiding these common mistakes will allow you to spend less time stressing over the oven and more time enjoying your tasty treats.